Piano, finally
Piano Finally is a podcast by an old bloke who is learning the piano, finally. I cover the process of learning the piano and music theory as an adult learner. I also review piano books, hardware and other materials from an adult learner's perspective.
Piano, finally
Episode 104 - On Paper
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
G'day, everyone. Welcome to show number one hundred and four of Piano, finally. Let's see if I can get everything right this week!
Welcome, I share some thoughts on renewing my Sydney Symphony Orchestra subscription and provide an update on the choir's progress for our December concert. We've got the repertoire sorted, and thankfully Sweet Disposition is reserved for the Perth festival, so I get a pass on that bass part! Also, a quick reminder that early-bird tickets for the 30th Blue Mountains Music Festival are available until mid-November: https://www.bmff.org.au/
What's been playing I have been enjoying Daniel Thrasher's fun classical pieces (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gStpYu84aRQ), a brilliant one-take cover of Pink Floyd's Money by sina-drums at Abbey Road Studios (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OMuG3XoOw0l), and Pierre Piscitelli's fascinating behind-the-scenes look at how he makes his videos (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OSYpQPZH43s).
Essay - On Paper: This week, I explore my approaches to using sheet music, and whether it is better on paper or digitally.I share my current setup, which involves some very nice Blackwing pencils (https://thesydneyartstore.com.au/collections/graphite/products/palomino-blackwing-soft-graphite) for paper scores, and a 13" iPad Pro running Newzik for digital scores.[cite: 4, 5] While digital is incredibly convenient for syncing finger numbers and annotations across devices, paper still has its place.[cite: 5, 6] Electronics will never replace browsing through Sappho Books (https://www.sapphobooks.com.au/) or DaCapo (https://www.dacapo.com.au/). Let's embrace both!
Learning - What's new: I've got the new practice space set up, placing the Yamaha Montage M8x in a spot where it gets played numerous times a day.[cite: 6, 7] I'm slowly but steadily working on Pierre Piscitelli's tutorial for Candle in the Wind. I'm also preparing to dive into Guy Michelmore's new course on Harmony.
Closing & Progress I'll be taking the Montage to the repairer to get the broken knob fixed. We also have a choir performance at the Parramatta Pride Picnic coming up. Finally, I share my progress with the Montage, experimenting with the opening of Candle in the Wind and the Trumpet Tune.
The contents of the podcast were entirely generated by David Reidy, but these show notes were created by Gemini.
You can contact me:
- via email at david@pianofinally.show; this is probably the best option
- the show website, www.pianofinally.show
- Instagram and Threads @pianofinally
- and on YouTube
- all the podcast directories - list
- here's the RSS feed
Some of the links to books and other items mentioned in the podcast may affiliate links for Amazon or other providers. If you use one of these links, a commission may be paid to me at no additional cost to you. Thank you if you use a link.
All reviews of products, websites and services are unpaid, and no sponsorship has been received for any content on this podcast.
Welcome
SPEAKER_00G'day everyone, I'm David Reedy. Welcome to Piano Finally, a podcast by an old bloke who's discovering music because he got around to learning the piano. Finally. Welcome to show number 104. Let's see if I can get everything right this week. If you've listened to the last show, you would have noticed that the little bits of bark that I used to separate the sections were missing. I used cue bass to put the show together, and those bits of music sit on their own track, one that can be independently muted, which is exactly what happened. There are usually four or five tracks that go to make up the show, as each sound source needs slightly different settings, and they all need to be on, so I'll be extra vigilant this week, though there are only three tracks, as I've only used one keyboard for the music. I have to start thinking about renewing the Sydney Symphony Orchestra subscription for next year. The five concert series is six hundred and twenty five dollars, or one hundred and twenty five dollars per concert, and I'm sort of in two minds. I enjoy the concerts and the talks beforehand, but I could also use the money for other smaller music events, or to support creators on Patreon. I have until November to decide to renew and keep my current seating, so there's no hurry. I've already got Bell Shakespeare and the Sydney Theatre Company subscriptions for next year, so I'll have to think carefully. There was a bass section and a general rehearsal for the choir this week. The general rehearsal was also the annual general meeting, which was just as exciting as every other annual general meeting I've ever been to. But everyone survived and we had a nice sing along afterwards. We're more than halfway through the repertoire for the December concert. Thankfully, Sweet Disposition is not one of the songs for December. We've been practicing it, but it will be sung at the choir festival in Perth, and I'm not attending that. I do like the song, but the bass part ranges to the F above Middle C, which is uncomfortable and doesn't sound particularly good. One last reminder, the Early Bird tickets for the Blue Mountains Music Festival are now available. The festival is in March next year, and as it's the thirtieth festival, they've got some big names lined up already. I'll put a link in the show notes to the ticket site. The Early Bird pricing runs until mid-November, unless they sell out earlier. Daniel Thrash's videos are often fun, and his latest in his series of composing
What's been playing
SPEAKER_00existing music is out with some classical pieces. These are fun, as a challenge to work out what it is that he's playing before each reveal. I got a couple of them in this new video. It's also nice that he puts the sponsor spot right at the very end of the video, making it really easy to skip over. Or to let it run but ignore it. I'm not sure if the video gets the money if you skip over the sponsorship, so generally I let it run and just don't pay attention. I have YouTube premium to avoid the other ads and because the creators get more money per view. There's a link to Daniel's video in the show notes. I like a lot of Pink Floyd's music, so I was glad I found a video by Sinodrums covering money. This is a recording made at Abbey Road Studios with a really interesting way of doing the introduction, which, as they say, Pink Floyd themselves never performed live. It's worth a watch. And if you do watch, keep going to the end. There's some bonus material after the end of the song. If you want to support live music, it's really worth watching. And there's a link in the show notes. Pierre Pisciatelli's latest video isn't another how to play video. It's a video about how he makes his videos. The first half covers the tools he uses to extract the instrumental tracks and then produce the sheet music. The second half looks at how everything is recorded and put together to produce the final video. If you've ever wondered about how these videos get done, this video by Pierre is well worth watching. You can probably guess where the link is.
Essay - On Paper
SPEAKER_00So I thought I'd let you know my ideas. They were talking about their approaches to using sheet music, and whether it is better on paper or digitally. I've got a pile of both, but I'm using one more and more rather than the other. I want to say at the outset that there is no one right answer as to which is best. It will depend upon a musician's preferences and situation. So I'll start with my setup. I need printed scores in a few different places. Firstly, I need them at the keyboard, or in my case now, keyboards. The main piano is in one room, and my synthesizer keyboard is in another room, at the other end of the house. I also need the music for my lessons, and I need the choral scores for choir practice. I also need to make annotations on the scores during lessons and at the rehearsals. The equipment I have available is as follows I have some very nice Blackwing pencils. I think I've reviewed these on the show, and they are by far the best and nicest pencils I've used for writing and note taking. They are expensive, but compared with the cost of almost everything else, they're worth it. They are perfect for making notes on paper at the piano. For digital copies of scores at the keyboard, I have a thirteen inch iPad Pro. Actually, I have two of them. I use the iPad in a magic keyboard case for teaching nearly every day. It's the iPad I have with me pretty much all of the time. I also still have my previous twelve point nine inch iPad Pro that I keep ready to go as a backup in case anything happens to the main unit. Having two might seem excessive, but they've become such an integral part of how I deliver lessons that having a backup makes good sense. Besides, as a teacher, I get a discount on hardware from Apple. I also have a MacBook Pro which I mostly use to prepare lessons and which I use for music some of the time, particularly for the choir scores and practice tracks. Of course, if all I needed to do was look at music, I could just print out multiple copies and keep one with each keyboard. I'm not learning so much music that that would be a problem. The problem is that I'm not just looking at the music. I'm often making notes, marking out finger numbers, or emphasizing bits that I would otherwise miss. And while I'm trying to avoid doing this, marking sharps and flats from the key signature onto the notes, especially on chords. I really want to get to the stage where that is unnecessary, and I just automatically play the right notes. It is these annotations that swing me most decisively towards using the iPad and digital copies of the music. The music comes as a PDF file, and instead of using a generic PDF reader, I use a piece of software called music. Music has a huge advantage that it makes the same annotations on every copy of the piece of music across all the devices. So if I write a finger number while I'm working on a piece at the Kawaii and later go to play it on the Yamaha, the iPad that stays with the montage has the finger number already there. If I later go to change the finger numbers on the Dorico file of the score, I can access the annotated PDF on the computer even when I'm not at home. When I go to choir practice or to my music lessons, I just have to remember to take the iPad, and I'm not trying to get together all the other different pieces of sheet music. Of course, the downside of using an electronic device is that it might run out of charge. Luckily, the phone carrier I use has one of those reward schemes that I never think about until they tell me the points are about to expire. One of the things the points can be used for are battery banks. So I now have two that live in my bag and have enough power to fully charge the iPad and the laptop. And in case you worry about fires, both the battery banks are well known, reputable brands, not cheap versions from AliExpress. That one convenience factor would be enough to make me move to digital, provided that I needed the equipment for other purposes too. It's an expensive option. Two iPad Pros would cost close to $5,000, and even using a pair of 13 inch iPad Airs would take the total equipment cost over $3,000. And I don't know if that's reasonable. I already have the equipment for work, and that's what justifies the cost. But it's not something I'd recommend if you don't already have some of the things that you need. And of course, you get the other advantages of digital music. Nearly every piece of music ever written is available for download. All of the classical repertoire is now in the public domain, so free copies of scores are often available. Music that is still under copyright can be purchased from any of a dozen online music stores. And in both cases, you get the music instantly. With the right software, page turning becomes a thing of the past. Foot pedals are common for linking to your iPad or other tablet, and some software can respond to facial gestures or listen to your playing and anticipate your needs. And finally, the text size is scalable for those who want to read bigger print. But paper still has its place. Having a physical copy of a score is still more satisfying than having a PDF file. Being able to see a collection of music books on the bookshelf is also motivating. It reminds you of just how much there is to learn and play. And it's much, much cheaper and resellable after you've finished with it. So which is better? Neither. Each can be the solution for different situations. Paper will always have a place, especially when it comes to just browsing through a bookstore. I don't think electronics will ever replace looking through the rooms at Sappho Books in Glebe or any other second hand bookstore. Add in the huge collection of music that is available upstairs at DeCapo, and even the shiniest technology will lose. On the other hand, paper will never replace being able to carry a hundred different pieces of music in a device weighing a few hundred grams. So let's embrace both. Oh, a postscript. The venue we use for most of our choir rehearsals is in a town hall. The council provides it free of charge to community groups, so often we are rehearsing there with an eco group meeting and there's a Scottish dance group that practices there and lots of other activities. It's a great resource and the council's support is very much appreciated. But it can take a while for maintenance problems to get resolved. We meet in the largest room and it has a lighting system that turns off automatically if movement isn't detected. Unfortunately, the movement detectors aren't working properly, so every 14 minutes the main lights turn off. There's still enough light to see to safely move around, but not enough to read a score by. Those of us with self-illuminating screens don't have a problem. I've
Learning - What's new
SPEAKER_00got the montage working with a computer to record audio, so this week some of the practice will end up in the progress section. The biggest change I've made to my learning in the past week though is getting the new practice space set up. The Kawaii NV10 is still the main piano, but I've put the montage in a spot where I walk past it numerous times a day. I used to have the Roland FX90 at one end of the hallway, but it's away on loan to someone. Since it's still new, the Yamaha is much more likely to get played. I've rearranged some more things, sorted out the piano benches, and now I have the montage in such a spot that I can stop, do a couple of minutes of work on the two pieces I'm concentrating on, and then move on. It's proving effective so far, with the addition of a half an hour of proper practice, remembering it's holidays at the moment, and I think I might actually be getting somewhere. I'm using Pierre Pisciatelli's tutorial for Candle in the Wind, and I've purchased the score, so I've got something to fall back on. It's coming along slowly but steadily, and it's sounding nice so far. I'm only going to play the very beginning this week though. I've joined Pierre's Patreon to support his work, and that got me looking through some of his back catalogue, and I've added two more tracks to my Pop Songs to Be Learned list. So sometime in the future I'll be adding Pierre's versions of Everybody Wants to Rule the World and Bruce Hornsby's The Way It Is. There are many, many more, but I'm determined to keep the list manageable. During the week I also put together the practice tracks for Dancing Queen for the choir. I'll talk about the process in an upcoming episode, but there have been a lot of things to learn about getting the software to sound just right. It's been a bit frustrating, but it's enjoyable learning new things. I still have Guy Mitchelmore's new course on writing a melody, though I haven't done much of that this week. I've been mainly tidying up around the house. Guy has a revamped course on harmony just out also. It's a tidy up and improvement to a pair of much older courses. There was a note with the new course to drop them a line if you had the older courses for a discount. They got back to me during the week, and the discount turned out to be a hundred percent, which was very nice of them. I haven't had a chance to look further than the introduction, but I'll give a proper report on the material in an upcoming episode.
Closing
SPEAKER_00I'm assuming that there will be a show next week. The choir has a performance on Saturday afternoon as part of the Parramatta Pride picnic, which will take up some of the weekend. But it's the holidays, so I still think I'll have plenty of time to get the show written and recorded. We're doing three songs at the picnic, and although we've learned them, we can have the scores with us, so that will make things simpler. I've organised to get the broken knob on the montage fixed. I'm taking it to the repair place when they give me a call to say they've got the parts in. This repairer will actually do a repair rather than just replace the whole controller board. I'm hoping it won't take too long. I've got a transport case for the keyboard. It's a good, strong, hard case, but with the keyboard inside it weighs over forty two kilograms. Just as well it has wheels. If you'd like to contact me, email is the best way. You'll find me at David at pianofinely.show and the website at www.pianofinely.show. In both cases, pianofinely is all one word. The show is also available on Spotify and as an audio only stream on YouTube. You can subscribe via any popular iOS or Android podcast application or from directories such as Apple Podcasts, Spotify or YouTube. I also post an excerpt and link for each episode as an Instagram reel. If you're learning an instrument or learning to sing, let me know where you are in your journey, what's going well, and what are the challenges, how are you managing your time, and which bits are you enjoying the most? This podcast is produced on the lands of the Darug and Gundangura peoples, land that always was and always will be traditional Aboriginal land. They were the first musicians in this place, and their song lines stretch back tens of thousands of years. I pay my respects to their elders past and present, and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people listening to the podcast. And so, until the next show, I hope your piano stays in tune and you enjoy your time at the Keys.
Progress
SPEAKER_00It's still experimenting with the keyboard's time. I'm using the break and the additional time to try out some new things. I'm still working on some of the more traditional pieces. I'll probably include them in a few weeks' time. The pop songs at the moment are proving to be more fun. This week I'll include what I've been playing around with on the Yamaha montage. It's the opening of Pierre Pisciatelli's arrangement of Candle in the Wind. I've also been playing the trumpet tune. With the trumpet tune, I've been working on getting both hands working well together and keeping the rhythm constant, that's proving harder. I think this has been benefiting most from the multiple short practices each day. It's the piece I tend to run through twice whenever I sit down at the montage. I recorded both pieces of music directly from the Yamaha Montage M8X via USB audio with one of the montage built-in performances for Elton John's piano. I made a couple of small changes to it though. I'm not convinced it's completely accurate and I'm going to keep looking into it. The trumpet tune is also from the montage using another one of the inbuilt piano performances.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Connected
Relay
Upgrade
Relay
No Such Thing As A Fish
No Such Thing As A Fish
We Can Be Weirdos
GlobalDownload This Show
ABC Australia
Stuff The British Stole
ABC Australia and CBC
The iDeveloper Podcast
Steve Scott (Scotty) & John FoxRaven On: A Pop Culture Podcast
Natalie Bochenski & Stuart Layt
Smart Enough to Know Better
Dan Beeston & Greg Wah
TopMusic Piano Podcast
Tim Topham
The Chopin Podcast
Garrick Ohlsson and Ben Laude